Friday, March 18, 2011
concerning Rob Bell's new book and the face of theology today
0 comments Posted by david sherwood at 1:24 PMOpening statements:
If an orthodoxy cannot withstand questions, it is already dead.
Teachers will face a double judgment
Yes I have Rob Bell's book, and no i haven't finished it. But the conclusions of the book are already in grave doubt because of the methodology of his arguments.
- His exegesis is terrible. He heads into using word studies as a way around difficult biblical realities. He often pulls texts from their paragraph because the paragraph itself wouldn't support his conclusions. He also simply ignores major texts that would work against his argument.
- He starts the book with a presupposition and reaction. A presupposition that God is so loving that Hell cannot possibly be what the bible and historical orthodoxy postulate that it is; and he didn't like what someone said in a note at his church art exhibit.
- His trying to lump Origin into being a representative of orthodoxy is suspect at best. Universalism is not part of the great big stream of historical orthodoxy.
- His use of questions as a rhetorical device is deeply manipulative and a dodge of responsibility. "Have you quit beating your wife," sort of questions.
- Don't do a good job with exegesis. Their logical and theological fallacies are often terrible.
- They use word studies and find obscure definitions to dodge difficult realities.
- In trying to be relevant they avoid the fact that the cross is a stumbling block.
- They don't like Gods wrath (and other things) so they seek to remove them.
- They quote historical [Ancient / Future] texts conveniently and often out of context.
- They say "i'm just asking a question" like it gives them license to speculate on anything.
- While deconstructionism is all fine and good for paradigm shifts, this group increasing tells you what they are against and don't like while being unable to clearly articulate their dogmatic doctrines.
- Ignore the Corinthians passages about love
- Ignore Matthew 18
- Gossip and slander through blogs and justify it through rationalizing it as truth telling / prophetic thus showing them to tip their hand that the means does justify the ends. They have no sense of ethics in how they accomplish their inquisitions and can justify almost anything with a defending-truth mantra of some sort
- Rarely show compassion in their confrontations
- Ask for repentance but show no initiative of reconciliation
- Are smug, arrogent, and prideful concerning truth in ways that are very ugly to those inside and outside the church
Thursday, October 7, 2010
Catalyst tension 2010
Our appetites for...food, sex, sleep, etc are high motivators in our lives
Desires are the drivers of our lives
Each appetite creates tension...because we always want more
Leadership tensions
Progress
Responsibility
Wins
Growth
Respect / Recognition / Fame / to be envied...jealousy
Achievement
Appetites:
God created them and Sin distorts them
Never fully and finally satisfied
Always whisper NOW and never later
Step 1 admit your reality
Your reaction to your appetites that are never and fully satisfied will determine the path and destination of your life
The internal battle must be won before the external war can be fought
Gen 25 Jacob and Essau
Both have appetites that are out of control
Birthrights and blessings deeply desired
Finances and inheritance
Position and respect-given authority over the rest of the family
Blessing...anointing and unique connection to God assumed
Essau: mans man fight club
Jacob: metrosexual, making dinner
Older bro never need younger bro
Younger bro always wants and needs something from older bro
But when the older bro needs something... The younger bro says hey let's pause while I figure out what I can get out of this. Negotiation trade.
The stupidest trade ever...because of inability to defer gratification
Who would throw away....for .....
Why?
Because we can't wait we want it now
Without this I will die! Bull... The appetite creates a brain impact bias and magnifies it completely out of proportion. Survival instinct on crack! Brain is lying to you and this is why you will have buyers remorse. And the brain does focalism where we see 1 thing and blur and forget everything else.
This happens every time an appetite gets provoked
This decision / these decisions are what Destroy the future!
Now decisions: good and bad are unleashed into the future like a bullet from a gun
The future essau: Moses lineage, Jesus, MatthewS gospel...
Look at your bowl again
It would be better if you died than if you did this
You are about to lose your future
YOU must mature enough to reframe your appetites
And God let's this happen.. Because the responsibility is OURS
This is the privilege and responsibility of freedom
If the appetite gets control
You will compromise everything to get it
10 years from now...
What do you want to see...desire to b an elder is a good thing
But
Control how you get there
What is your bowl of stew?
What are you desperate for to create excitement or ease the pain?
Talk yourself off the cliff?
What is not illegal or immoral that you do but you wish nobody ever found out about?
Make no private decision that can't stand up on a public stage
This pushes the appetite back into the right context
The Jonathan Edwards reality
The resolutions
The graveyard
And you are not just trading your stuff you are trading others hope, faith, etc.
Refrain
Retrain
Retame
And maintain
Or lose to good plans God has for you!
Labels: Catalyst 2010
Friday, August 27, 2010
So here's the deal. Your computer is depressed, it's slow, it;s sad, and frankly it's depressed. You've tried to install patches, a new OS, and even some new security features. But it still just won't work right. So you go to some online forums to get some advice, but nobody really gives you anything new. Finally, after coming to the conclusion that you can't fix it yourself you make a cell-phone call to service. They tell you to go to a chatroom and they walk you through a bunch of stuff that doesn't work either. Then the worst thing happens, you get a virus and it just messes with everything. You don't know what you did wrong to download the virus but nothing you try gets it out and everything is screwed up. Now there is only one thing left to do. But you don't like it. There is a service where you go on-line and let a remote host have access to your computer. It's kind of freaky because you can see the disembodied mouse moving around on your screen doing whatever it wants to. Plus it makes you feel stupid watching it, because it will write weird coded stuff on black pop-up screens and actually change the software; all that stuff us mere mortals don't know how to do. At first it's not to bad, but then the operator asks for some passwords for some protected parts of the machine. You know; bank account stuff, internet history, and some other places that you aren't sure you want to open up. So you lie, and say you'll have to be back to them because you can't remember those pass codes right now. And then you sit there and are just stuck. Because while all this stuff sounds mechanical, intellectual, and scientific the fact remains that you will have to trust this person before anything changes. And we don't like trusting some ethereal and faceless stranger with our pass codes, secrets, bank account information, and web history. So now you will have to sit back an weigh your options. A new Mac is too expensive. Staying with the way things are is increasingly impossible. But am I willing to risk trusting this person? A person who if i let them in to total access could fix or destroy everything.
You walk away to think and feel your way through that decision.
It's so weird to let a stranger into your house. But then to let them access the fridge, and your checkbook is even weirder. What if they...?! And when it gets really weird is if they sneak into bed with you, yikes! And then...worst case scenario...they can even read your thoughts and feelings and motivations. Epic-weirdness!
my point?
These are all freakishly bizarre scenarios. So let me make it even stranger. What if this person loved you in spite of all the crazy stuff they have discovered about you. What if they had completely pure motivations and wanted into your life not for what they could get out of you but for what they could give you? Would you let them in, would you trust them, would you risk it?
This is after all, all about you and God. And God is both patient as well as intrusive in these sort of things. He wants into your hardrive. HHe wants into your checking account. And yes, he wants into your web browsing history. He wants remote access to all those password protected areas because of the virus that is infecting everything [the trojan horse we call 'sin'.] He wants full disclosure, full access, and full administrator rights and privileges. And as you sit in your seat you are gonna have to decide if you trust him or not. Not just a reaching-in-faith towards belief trust; but a rubber-hits-the-road of reality trust. In a good way, Jesus wants to go viral in you. He wants to shine his love, hope, power, peace, grace, discipline, truth, light...into every square millimeter and milibite of your life.
What's a practical atheist? A practical atheist is someone who believes in God but acts like He doesn't exist. Or to put it another way, they let God unto the computer but keep massive sections out of his reach. Places like sex, money, painful memories, etc. The sort of relationship where we say we have a relationship with God but really we are just acquaintances that chit chat from time to time.
So here is what I suggest you do when you get back to that computer that's busted up in epic-fail mode. I suggest you go all-in and trust the disembodied techie and let them have remote access and control of everything. Let God have it all. He will be patient, and we will try to keep him out. But simply choose to hand him they keys to every room of your life. And i'll promise you something. This "stranger" will become trustworthy to you. Because trust is earned, and it can only be earned if we risk. Every great story of faith is a story of risking trusting God.